So, the list is uploaded and regularly updated by Korea Animal Rights Advocates (KARA) site (here's the Korean site). The list isn't all about skincare and makeup although 90% of it is. I put a little description for brands who aren't skincare/makeup brands.
Let's jump onto the list. The list is divided into 4 categories with 3 indicators:
- No animal testing
- No animal ingredients; and
- The company doesn't export to China
Everyone (well, almost) is mad over China's policy regarding the animal testing. But throughout the years, many parties have pressured and lobbied the government to stop the act. Also, foreign cosmetic brands' popularity in China has been increasing which then push the government to open the door wider. (For more articles and references, please do google them. Maybe I'll talk more about it later. One day.)
Before any of you ask, "Etude has physical stores in China and Krystal's face is everywhere (my princess), but why is it on the list?", let us sit and do a little more research. Everything is on the internet, darling.
Most (if not almost all) Korean cosmetic brands don't test on animals. So the main problem is why do they export to China? Well, obviously, China's market is huge. But then, how do those brands get away from the mandatory animal testing policy? According to an article written by Charlotte Cho on sokoglam, "... cosmetic companies can have ingredients listed on a “whitelist” that allows the product to be sold without animal testing."
Let's assume the whitelist consists of ingredients that are considered safe already by China's Food and Drug Administration. So that leads to another question. Many western brands claim to be cruelty-free, but because they still export to China, people don't believe them. Maybe they used to test on animals, but not anymore. Are they still not considered as cruelty-free (look at how those Korean brands work)?
But really, China's government just wants the products used by their people to be safe and according to some articles, they are open to new method of testing (no bodynotes because I closed the tabs before saving the article links. Guys, it's midnight and I've been editing this post alone for more than two hours).
Anyway, here's the list.
Source: ekara.org, accessed March 17, 2017
Let me re-type the list and link them (or you can just go to the original page).
Category 1
(no animal testing and ingredients; doesn't export to China)
allNature
ECO ROUND (aka Malgeunnara) (detergent and body care)
BYHERB
Skincure
sevendrops
Aromatica
aida cosmetic
A:TRUE
onsiya (hair and body care)
TREEANNSEA
HaemilLia
everain
evecondoms (condoms, duh)
Coslys (the link doesn't work Idk)
Sugar StripEase (hair removal)
Bebecell (skincare for babies)
with my
Beautiqlo
bebeskin (skincare for babies)
The soonsoo
L'arbrevert (dish soap)
ECO ROUND (aka Malgeunnara) (detergent and body care)
BYHERB
Skincure
sevendrops
Aromatica
aida cosmetic
A:TRUE
onsiya (hair and body care)
TREEANNSEA
HaemilLia
everain
evecondoms (condoms, duh)
Coslys (the link doesn't work Idk)
Sugar StripEase (hair removal)
Bebecell (skincare for babies)
with my
Beautiqlo
bebeskin (skincare for babies)
The soonsoo
L'arbrevert (dish soap)
Category 2
(no animal testing; doesn't export to China)
NMC
ISNTREE
SIDMOOL
eco (Nature's Friend)
Beauty Recipe
BEYOND
SKINEYE
SKIN WATCHERS
Bonajour
Klairs
Dr. Bronner's
Lush
Nablus soap (body care)
Logona
John Paul Pet (pet grooming aka skincare for your pet lol)
&tree
Rokkiss
ISNTREE
SIDMOOL
eco (Nature's Friend)
Beauty Recipe
BEYOND
SKINEYE
SKIN WATCHERS
Bonajour
Klairs
Dr. Bronner's
Lush
Nablus soap (body care)
Logona
John Paul Pet (pet grooming aka skincare for your pet lol)
&tree
Rokkiss
Category 3
(no animal testing and ingredients)
MAY ISLAND
Half Moon Eyes
Category 4
(no animal testing)
Lolita Lempicka (perfumery)
Out of all those names, the most familiar ones for international consumers (well, at least, for me) are on the fourth category which are mostly owned by Amore Pacific Group. Amore Pacific Group currently holds the highest market share and dubs as South Korea's largest seller of beauty and personal care products. (LG Household and Health Care places second with a slightly smaller market share than Amore Pacific Group, FYI).
Let's do some more research and discuss them!
Thank you for this list! Very helpful and detailed. :) I'm having some trouble finding most of cf and vegan brands on eBay but I did manage to find some aromatica, Sidmool and Beyond products so I'll start with those.
ReplyDeleteyou're welcome. very glad to know that :)
DeleteI saw that Sidmool use milk/milk extracts in their products.. So I think are not vegan unfortunately...
DeleteMany thank's for the list. I'm looking for information about "secret key" , Do you know if they are cruelty-free too?
ReplyDeleteI visited the official website and found that some products were not tested on animals (they stated it on the description bar). that's the only information that I could get. sorry if I didn't help much, but thanks for dropping by btw :)
DeleteWow, what fun music! :) enjoyable.
ReplyDeleteThis is SO helpful. I was going nuts trying to find some brands that I knew were in this list, but couldn't understand. Thank you!!!
ReplyDeleteyou're welcome. glad it helped :)
Deletehey, sweetheart. can you find out if.. idk what's the name i guess it's peripera. does it included in cruelty free? i'm thinking of having one. please help me and thanks in advance!♡
ReplyDeleteHi! :)
DeleteAnyway, I did a little bit of research. FYI, Peripera (along with Clio) is part of Club Clio. I went to Naver (Korean site) and found a blog. The author called Clio directly to ask wheter the products are cruelty-free or not and the company rep said that they didn't test on animals and even though they exported to China, they didn't test on animals.
Hope that can help. Thanks for visitin btw :)
If they export to China and sell in that country in a physical store, then they must test on animals. And they are listed on Ulta's China site, which means they do sell physically there. Concerning that they would lie.
Delete@MeowMars007 according to some articles that I read, companies can sell products in China without having to test on animals (https://sokoglam.com/blogs/news/113436357-all-you-need-to-know-about-cruelty-free-cosmetics and some other resources that I did read but forgot the links sorry). there are many Korean brands which sell their products in China and still cruelty-free.
DeleteHi,thanks for researching and sharing your findings. I was wondering if you know whether the ingredients used by Peripera all vegan?
DeleteHello! I was hoping you might have some info on Holika Holika and Lioele? It seems they do not respond to e-mails.
ReplyDeleteFor Holika Holika, I found out that their products has this 'cruelty-free' label on the box but they still use animal ingredients ex snail. For Lioele, according to this (http://www.lioeletexas.com/Lioele_FAQ_s/1826.htm), they don't test on animals.
DeleteHow about it's skin and missha?
ReplyDeleteIm having real trouble finding information about The Face Shop. Is this brand cruelty free/vegan or not?
ReplyDeleteAny news? I'm struggling too!
Deletehey, could you please tell if 3w clinic, ekel, and entel are cruelty free or not?
ReplyDeleteHow about Precious?
ReplyDeleteThis blog is really helpful regarding all educational knowledge I earned. It covered a great area of subject which can assist a lot of needy people. Everything mentioned here is clear and very useful.
ReplyDeleteหน้าใสไร้สิว
does peripera use animal-derived ingredients? I'd be very thankful if you respond. Thank youu
ReplyDeletedoes peripera use animal-derived ingredients? I'd be very thankful if you respond. Thank youu
ReplyDeleteJust wondering where "thefaceshop" sits on this category?
ReplyDeleteThank you very much for this list! I linked your post in my latest blogpost: http://theniceadvice.com/blog/2017/10/13/shops-buy-korean-beauty-part4/
ReplyDeletedoes treeannsea use animal-derived ingredients?
ReplyDeleteI'm not sure how often this is updated, but I did want to share my response from the website Peach & Lily concerning the brands they represent. You can take this with a grain of salt because I'm not super familiar with all of the regulations and rules that go into confirming cruelty free/no animal testing. I will say that I was very pleased with the quickness of response and the transparency they seemed to be willing to give.
ReplyDeleteMar 2, 00:00 EST
Hi! I've been wanting to try many of the brands on your website for awhile, but since I only use cruelty-free products I was hoping to find out if you had a list of which brands were animal tested and which ones were not.
I would appreciate it greatly to be informed if there are finished products and/or individual ingredients that are animal tested by any of the brands you represent. If it is also possible, is there a list for the brands that export and sell in China?
Thank you so much for your time,
Kaci
Peach & Lily Team (Peach and Lily)
Mar 2, 08:19 EST
Hello Kaci,
We hope you're well! Below are our brands that have provided us with a cruelty free guarantee. This does NOT mean that the other brands use animal testing, it simply means that we have reached out to confirm and have not heard a response back.
Aromatica
Ariul
Atopalm
Be the Skin
Caolion
Cremorlab
Femmue
Lady&Skin
Lagom
Leaders
The Lotus
May Coop
Morihata
Mizon
Peach & Lily
Peach Slices
Shangpree
Tosowoong
We hope this helps! Please let us know if you have anymore questions.
Kind Regards,
Peach & Lily Team
Join us on Facebook, Twitter, Instagram, Tumblr, and Pinterest
Hey I’m Martin Reed,if you are ready to get a loan contact.Mr Benjamin via email: lfdsloans@lemeridianfds.com,WhatsApp:+1 989-394-3740 I’m giving credit to Le_Meridian Funding Service .They grant me the sum 2,000,000.00 Euro. within 5 working days. Le_Meridian Funding Service is a group investors into pure loan and debt financing at the returns of 1.9% to pay off your bills or buy a home Or Increase your Business. please I advise everyone out there who are in need of loan and can be reliable, trusted and capable of repaying back at the due time of funds.
ReplyDeleteInteresting and amazing how your post is! It Is Useful and helpful for me That I like it very much, and I am looking forward to Hearing from your next.. Metaphysical Store
ReplyDelete